After author and educator Deanne Carson proposed that parents should ask their children’s permission before changing their diapers, she was hit with a barrage of criticism, igniting a contentious controversy.

In her remarks, which were broadcast on ABC News, Carson promoted what she called a “culture of consent” in homes, advising parents to get newborns’ vocal assent before changing their diapers. Some have criticized her position as ridiculous and unrealistic, while others have praised her early attempts to advance bodily autonomy.

Host Rowan Dean made harsh comments about the program, which was later shown on Sky News Australia’s “Outsiders” show. He called the proposal “leftie lunacy” and made fun of the idea of asking babies for their assent. The ensuing online furor propelled Carson into the spotlight, prompting her to defend her position on social media.

In a Facebook post addressing her critics, Carson reaffirmed the importance of teaching consent to young children, citing alarming statistics on sexual assault to underscore the urgency of her message. Despite her impassioned plea, Carson’s remarks have drawn both praise and condemnation from netizens, highlighting the polarizing nature of her advocacy.

While some have lauded Carson for her dedication to abuse prevention and championing children’s rights, others have lambasted her approach as excessive and outlandish. Former New South Wales Senate candidate Kirralie Smith went so far as to label Carson’s proposal as “neglect and child abuse,” arguing that it disregards the practicalities of childcare and infant hygiene.

Yet amidst the uproar, voices of support have emerged, with advocacy groups like Facts Without Frenzy rallying behind Carson’s cause. They argue that her teachings align with international best practices in abuse prevention and provide crucial guidance for parents navigating sensitive conversations with their children.

Many people are now struggling with difficult issues related to consent, bodily autonomy, and the responsibility of caregivers to cultivate positive relationships with their children as a result of the debate. Some argue that Carson’s suggestions trivialize the seriousness of problems like sexual assault, while others see them as a progressive step forward that verges perilously near to ridiculousness.

One thing is certain as the debate continues: Carson’s demand for consent in childcare has sparked a flurry of controversy that doesn’t seem to be going away. Only time will tell if her suggestions mark a radical change in parenting standards or an overreach gone wrong. Until then, passionate voices from both sides of the aisle will continue to fuel the debate.